We have over 2,150 reviews on Google, and instead of just citing the number, we pulled the full review archive and actually read through it: what guests mention most, what they rate highest, and what they say in their own words about visiting one of New York's largest haunted attractions.

The numbers

• 2,150 total reviews, 4.3★ average
• 1,341 include written comments, not just a star rating
• Guests mention the actors and scares, the hayride, and the value in roughly a quarter of reviews each
• One in ten guests overwhelmingly positively mention staff or customer service
• Family and group visits come up in one in ten reviews

"It's not a haunted house, it's an experience"

Read enough reviews back to back and the same idea keeps surfacing: people aren't describing one attraction, they're describing a full night out.

"I'm literally obsessed with this place. I've gone like 7 years in a row. It's not a haunted house, it's an experience — hayride, tons of haunted houses, corn maze, illusionist show, and a whole little village with food and donuts." — Simone, 5★

"This is a very Disney-like experience and worth every cent. Being from Long Island, we have been to dozens, and this by far is the best and most intense experience we have had. Sets, actors and staff were FANTASTIC." — Delia, 5★

"My favorite Halloween tradition for the past 20 years & hands down the best haunted attraction I have ever been to. The actors & sets are like being submerged into your own horror movie." — Catherine, 5★

Read more …